Immigration

The Challenges of the New Protection Approach

Blog
Alarm clock beside a calendar

Our dedicated immigration team outlines recent changes to UK Immigration Rules, including the 30-month refugee stay to proposed 20-year settlement journeys, and the challenges they present for the communities we work alongside.

On 5th March 2026, the government published a statement of changes to the Immigration rules which outline a more restrictive set of rules for people who claimed asylum on or after 2nd March 2026.

Under the previous rules, people whose asylum claims were approved by the Home Office were granted 5 years of refugee status. At the end of this 5-year permission to stay, refugees were able to apply for settlement free of charge and settle in the UK permanently, an approach described by the Home Office as “generous compared to some of our European neighbours”.

The Home Office has now introduced a revised system which it says meets its “international obligations but do[es] not exceed them”. As part of the new rules, individuals whose asylum claims are successful will receive 30 months’ permission to stay to remain on a protection route.

The changes apply to all claims submitted on or after the 2nd March 2026, unless the applicant is an unaccompanied asylum-seeking child. The 30-months permission to stay can be renewed before the expiry at which point the Home Office will assess whether protection is still required, depending on the country the individual is seeking protection from. If the Home Office determines that conditions in that country have improved sufficiently and the individual no longer requires protection, their permission to stay may not be extended which will result in them having to explore different options to remain lawfully in the UK or make arrangements to leave.

Parallel to these changes, the Home Office has announced policy proposals under the ‘Earned Settlement’ model which, if implemented, mean that refugees will have to complete at least 20 years of lawful residence in the UK before being able to settle. For many people, the proposed changes could mean waiting even longer than this before they are able to qualify.

The Challenges

As an organisation who has been providing expert support and casework to people who migrate for more than 25 years, we are well placed to anticipate and support our communities through the challenges which may arise as a result of the proposed changes.

Firstly, under these proposals, refugees will be expected to renew their stay a minimum of eight times, over a period of at least 20 years. In reality, many individuals may need to remain for even longer before becoming eligible for settlement. Our experience of supporting people on a 10-year route to settlement shows that extended periods of limited leave can create significant challenges for individuals and families, leaving them facing uncertainty about their future in the UK. Recent reports have also linked these routes to poverty and financial instability.

Reapplying means repeatedly gathering documents, completing applications, and seeking legal advice and support, over time, this can place emotional and practical pressure on families and increase demand on support services. We remain determined to offer support, both legal and practical to the members of our community affected by these changes. Our immigration casework team will continue to issue policy responses and reports, as well as providing front line casework to those seeking immigration advice. Further to this, we will support our communities with the financial and employment repercussions, as well as community support groups and health and wellbeing resources.

Applicants will also be required to repeatedly demonstrate that they are still facing risks and need protection. Most asylum seekers arrive in the UK having experienced significant trauma resulting from conflict, persecution, bereavement, and dangerous journeys. The asylum process itself can also be emotionally challenging, often requiring individuals to recount painful experiences in detail during lengthy interviews and evidential assessments. Requiring applicants to go through this process every two and a half years will create additional emotional strain, creating additional barriers to asylum seekers establishing stability, feeling secure, and rebuilding their lives. Our Designated Safeguarding Leads and Health and wellbeing teams will seek to support community members through these circumstances, as well as leading on partnership projects such as our on-going partnership with Doctors Without Borders (MSF) supporting those who have experienced significant trauma, though this does not negate the additional strain such changes could have.

Concerns over these proposals have been raised by the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), the authoritative international body on refugees, stressing ‘such a change would place additional administrative and costly burdens on the asylum system, create greater uncertainty for refugees and negatively affect integration and social cohesion’ while also reiterating its position that ‘refugees and others in need of international protection are provided with a secure and stable protection status that is not subject to constant review’.

The new 30 months renewal system bears similarities to the existing parent or partner routes, with which we have extensive experience. Through our work, we have developed an understanding of the difficulties many individuals face during the renewal process. Due to the existing backlogs, the current processing times for similar applications is approximately 12 months. These are 12 months in which applicants are left uncertain about their future, 12 months in which they cannot travel, even for urgent family emergencies, and 12 months in which they may face difficulties maintaining employment or accessing support. While applications made on time are covered by Section 3C, which extends the conditions of their previous leave until a decision is made, this provision is not always fully understood by employers. Because employers face serious penalties for employing someone without the right to work, many are reluctant to continue employing people whose status is covered by Section 3C leave. Therefore, under the new rules, refugees could face repeated periods where their right to work is questioned, affecting their financial stability every 30 months.

Although the new system has been presented as a means of encouraging refugees “to work and contribute to the UK”, it may have the opposite effect. Requiring people to repeatedly demonstrate and renew their right to remain and work in the UK could create barriers to employment and financial instability, making it harder for them to build their lives and contribute over the long term.

It is also anticipated that the introduction of this process will create an additional administrative burden for the Home Office. This may further increase existing delays, despite previous commitments to reduce processing times and improve efficiency.

Conclusion

While the Home Office has stated that these changes are intended to create a system that meets international obligations without exceeding them, some may view this approach as providing only the minimum level of protection required rather than demonstrating a broader commitment to helping people who seek sanctuary rebuild their lives. There are also serious concerns about the long-term impact this approach may have on individuals and the wider immigration system.

A successful protection system should provide not only safety from persecution, but also stability, certainty and a genuine opportunity for individuals to rebuild their lives. Requiring people to repeatedly prove their need for protection over potentially decades risks creating ongoing uncertainty and may hinder integration, employment opportunities and emotional recovery.

Based on our experience, we anticipate that these changes may place additional pressure not only on those seeking protection, but also on employers, support organisations and the Home Office itself.

Despite this, we will continue to provide specialist casework and support services to ensure that even in the face of additional challenges introduced as a result of these changes, our communities are best placed to maintain stability and build a future in which they can thrive.

If you require advice or support regarding these changes, you can access support via the following:

  • Contact your local hub – See Our Hubs page to find out how to access support in your local area.
  • Call us – If you live in Birmingham, call 0800 0663 444 to enquire about support.
  • Enquiry form – If you live in Birmingham, complete our online form with details of the support you need.

Get In Touch

General: For general enquiries email info@rmccharity.org.uk or call 0800 0663 444

For specific enquiries around fundraising, events, media or jobs please reach out:

Media

For all press, media and comms related enquiries contact: info@rmccharity.org.uk

Fundraising

For fundraising related enquiries and any questions around donations contact: funding@rmccharity.org.uk

Vacancies

For enquiries about RMC jobs, interviews and applications contact: vacancies@rmccharity.org.uk

Other

For any other enquiries, not related to getting support from RMC, contact: info@rmccharity.org.uk